U.S. Green Card Versus U.S. Citizenship: Is it Worth it to Naturalize?

In this article we compare the pros and cons of becoming a U.S. citizen, and whether or not it’s worth it to naturalize.

The naturalization process is far from easy. The time, paperwork, fees, and general requirements may seem intimidating to some, leaving many wondering whether it is even worth it to naturalize. After all, once you have your green card you can stay in the United States and work. Life doesn’t seem so bad, so why bother?

This article will compare the benefits of being a legal permanent resident (i.e. a green card holder) versus becoming a U.S. citizen.

Right to Stay in the United States

Permanent Residents

As a permanent resident, you have a right to stay in the United States indefinitely, provided that you do not engage in a deportable action. There are many grounds of deportability for permanent residents. Among the most common are:

  • Conviction of certain crimes;
  • Committing fraud; and
  • Failing to report a change of address[i]

U.S. Citizens

As a citizen, you have an unqualified right to stay in the United States and you will no longer have to notify USCIS every time you move. Once you are naturalized as a citizen, you will no longer be subject to the grounds of deportability that you were as a permanent resident. However, there are extremely limited situations where you can lose your citizenship through denaturalization. For more information of denaturalization, see this article.

Right to Work in the United States

Permanent Residents

Permanent residents are authorized to work in the United States. As a green card holder, you can hold almost any job you please. However, there are many government jobs you will not be eligible for and you would not be able to hold a public office in most cases.

U.S. Citizens

Citizens of the United States can have any job they are qualified for. Citizens, unlike permanent residents, can run for public office and can apply for all sorts of government jobs. Moral of the story: If you want an unfettered right to employment, then you should consider naturalization.

Right to Travel Abroad

Permanent Residents

As a permanent resident, you may travel abroad, but you must take care to maintain you residency status. If your trips are brief, then you should be okay. However, longer trips, especially those that are upward of a year, may raise questions.

Your resident status may be considered abandoned if you raise any doubt that you do not intend for the United States to be your permanent home. So, when traveling abroad, be sure you do not lead USCIS to believe that you will not be returning. At the very least, maintain your address here in the U.S. and be sure to file your income taxes. If you plan on a long trip abroad, consider applying for a reentry permit before leaving.

In the event that your residency is considered abandoned, you will have to go through the entire green card process again. You will lose any amount of continuous stay that you had previously built up.

U.S. Citizens

As a U.S. citizen, you are eligible for a U.S. passport and are free to travel abroad as often and for as long as you would like. You will generally have no problem reentering the United States because you are now a citizen of this great nation.

Right to Live Abroad

Permanent Residents

If you are permanent resident, then you must not live abroad. You must maintain your home in the United States. If you move abroad, then you risk your residency being considered abandoned. And, as we discussed above, this can cause a great deal of headache.

U.S. Citizens

If you are a citizen of the United States, then you are free to move to another country for as long as you’d like without losing any rights here in the United States.

Right to Obtain Public Assistance and Benefits

Permanent Residents

As a permanent resident, you will have rights to certain forms of public assistance. However, your eligibility may be greatly limited.

For instance, you will immediately be eligible for emergency Medicaid. For virtually all other Federal aids, however, you will not be eligible until you have been a permanent resident for five years.

Your eligibility for public benefits from your state may vary greatly from state to state.

U.S. Citizens

Unlike permanent residents, U.S. citizens are immediately eligible for all forms of aid on both the federal and state levels, so long as they meet the other requirements.

Right to Petition for Relatives to Enter the United States

Permanent Residents

As a permanent resident, you may petition for certain relatives to come to the United States. These relatives include your spouse and your unmarried children.

U.S. Citizens

U.S. citizens can petition for even more relatives than a permanent resident can. A U.S. citizen can petition for his or her spouse, children, parents, and siblings.

For more information about family-based green cards, check out our post: Who can apply for a green card?

Additionally, certain family members of U.S. citizens, such as your spouse, children, and parents, are considered “immediate relatives” under immigration law. This means they do not have to wait for a visa since an unlimited number of visas may be issued to immediate relatives of U.S. citizens.

Right to Vote

Permanent Residents

Permanent residents cannot vote in Federal elections nor in many state or local elections. Voting is a cornerstone of American democracy. It is how the people are heard. It is how we govern this nation. If you want to have your interests represented and the interests of others like you represented, then it is paramount that you are engaged in our government. And there is no stronger way than through the ballot.

U.S. Citizens

As you can probably guess, once you are a naturalized citizen, you can vote in all elections. Let your voice be heard. Protect your interests and even protect the interests of those who do not have a voice—those immigrants who have not yet reached the point you have, those still waiting in line for their chance at citizenship.

Conclusion

All in all, there are not many differences between the rights of permanent residents and U.S. citizens. But, among these small differences, some of them are priceless. The freedom and the power that come with citizenship in our great nation is easily worth the hard work it takes to naturalize.

If you want to naturalize, or if you want more information on naturalization, then check out our free resources that can put you on the path to success.

If you want to know more about the benefits and disadvantages of permanent residency and citizenship, consider scheduling a consultation with an experienced immigration attorney.


[i] See 8 U.S.C. § 1227.

Need an attorney?

Our articles provide general information about all of our practice areas. If you're looking for legal counsel specific to your situation, you'll need to talk to a lawyer.

Share This